Information Tribunal - join the Appeal or not ? - now set for 12,13,14 and 16th March 2007 at Procession House, London

| 1 Comment

We seem to slow shuffling along into the unexplored swamps of the Freedom of Information Act appeals process.

We have received a heavy packet of papers from the Information Tribunal as an "interested party" in the pending Appeal by the Office for Government Commerce against the Information Commissioner's Decision Notice in favour of disclosing the early, and now obsolete, Gateway Reviews of the Home Office's potentially disastrous Identity Cards Programme scheme.

See "Treasury hires expensive lawyers to try to overturn the Decision Notice in our favour regarding Gateway Reviews of the Identity Cards Programme"

This is all well and good, but if we do "join the appeal", it will then be held partly or totally in private, precisely to prevent us, the original Freedom of Information Act request complainant from being shown or hearing any extracts of the Gateway Review reports in question.

Both the lawyers for the Information Commissioner and the Treasury Solicitor Grainne Ross, would not object to us being joined to the Appeal, but they both point out the limited value of any possible written or oral submissions that we could make, since the Gateway Review documents would still be kept secret from us during the proceedings.

We agree with these views, and so we are resigned to having to wait whilst large sums of public money are wasted on legal fees during this Appeal, which we firmly believe should still find in our favour i.e. in favour of the public interest of full public disclosure and publication of these documents.

The other hugely frustrating thing is the it seems that the Oral hearing for the Appeal is set for a 4 day hearing not before 5th March 2007
i.e. 2 years and 3 months after the original Freedom of Information Act request

This lengthy delay, and complicated proceedings, and expensive legal fees paid for by the taxpayer, run completely counter to the supposed "open government" policy, which the Freedom of Information Act is supposed to promote.

We will write to John Angel, the Chairman of the Information Tribunal accordingly.


According to the Information Tribunal Pending Appeals document dated 6th December 2006 (.pdf), It looks as if the Appeal hearing is now set for

Full hearing 12,13,14 and 16th March 2007 at Procession House London

Information Tribunal P.O. Box 6987 Leicester LE1 6ZX

Tel: 0845 600 0877
Direct Line 0116 249 4322
Fax 0116 249 4253
Website www.information

Our ref: EA/2006/0068


Date 25 Oct. 06

Dear Mr. XXX

Re Office of Government Commerce v the information Commissioner

The Tribunal has received notice from the Office of Government Commerce in relation to the information Commissioner's Decision Notice to which you are the named complainant. The Tribunal considers it would be desirable as someone with an interest in the proceedings to be invited to apply to be joined as a party to the appeal under rulle 7 of the Information tribunal (Enforcement Appeals) Rules 2005, a copy of which is enclosed.

See Statutory Instrument 2005 No. 14 The Information Tribunal (Enforcement Appeals) Rules 2005 section 7 Joinder of other persons to appeals

In order for you to consider this invitation we enclose the notice of appeal and Commissioner's reply. Also we enclose the directions order which sets out the steps which need to be taken by the parties to prepare.for the hearing. You will see that the appeal in relation to your complaint is being considered with another appeal, because common questions of law and fact arise in both appeals. We enclose the notice of appeal in that appeal to help you with your decision on whether to apply to be joined.

Our appeal is EA/2006/068 (ICO reference FS50070196)

This other appeal is case EA/2006/081 (ICO references FS50132936 and FS50083104) which was refers to a request for the "traffic light status" of the Identity Cards Programme, which is supposed to be one of the outputs of the Gateway Reviews.

This was originally framed as a Parliamentary Written Question by the then Liberal Democrat Home Affairs spokesman Mark Oaten MP for WInchester, to the Chancellor of the Exchequer, before it got turned into a Freedom of Information Act Request to be handled by Her Majesty's Treasury's Office for Government Commerce, by mutual consent.

See the Information Commissioner's Decision Notice database for summaries and links to the full text of both Decision Notices against the Office for Government Commerce

The arguments by the Treasury and OGC for keeping things secret, and those by the Information Commissioner citing the public interest and the duty of civil servants and private sector consultants, to give their best possible professional advice, regardless of whether or not this anonymous adbice is published some time in the future, are virtually the same as in our Decision Notice.

It seems unlikely that Mark Oaten MP will see any value in being joined to this appeal either, for the same reasons as mentioned above.

Please not that if joined you will be subject to the direction order and that some evidence will withheld [sic] from you before and at the hearing in order to maintain confidentiality. For an explanation as to why this is necessary we would refer you to the Tribunal's practice direction dated March 2006, which is available on our web site.

See the Information Tribunal's Practice Directions (.pdf)

If you wish to be joined you must do so by 10th November 2006 by writing to the Tribunal at the above address.

Yours sincerely

Information Tribunal
proper Officer

1 Comment

Love the blog here. Nice colors. I am definitely staying tuned to this one. Hope to see more.

Leave a comment

About this blog

This United Kingdom based blog has been spawned from Spy Blog, and is meant to provide a place to track our Freedom of Information Act 2000 requests to United Kingdom Government and other Public Authorities.

If you have suggestions for other FOIA requests,  bearing in mind the large list of exemptions, then email them to us, or use the comments facility on this blog, and we will see  what we can do, without you yourself having to come under the direct scrutiny of  "Sir Humphrey Appleby" or his minions.

Email Contact

Please feel free to email us your views about this website or news about the issues it tries to comment on:

email: blog @spy[dot]org[dot]uk

Here is our PGP public encryption key or download it via a PGP Keyserver. - FOIA request submission and publication website from

Campaign Buttons

Campaign for the Freedom of Information

NO2ID - opposition to the Home Office's Compulsory Biometric ID Card
NO2ID - opposition to the Home Office's Compulsory Biometric ID Card and National Identity Register centralised database.

Watching Them, Watching Us, UK Public CCTV Surveillance Regulation Campaign
UK Public CCTV Surveillance Regulation Campaign

Peaceful resistance to the curtailment of our rights to Free Assembly and Free Speech in the SOCPA Designated Area around Parliament Square and beyond

Parliament Protest blog - resistance to the Designated Area restricting peaceful demonstrations or lobbying in the vicinity of Parliament.

Amnesty International 's campaign

Yes, Minister

Yes, Minister Series 1, Episode 1, "Open Government" First airtime BBC: 25 February 1980

"Bernard Woolley: "Well, yes, Sir...I mean, it [open government] is the Minister's policy after all."
Sir Arnold: "My dear boy, it is a contradiction in terms: you can be open or you can have government."

FOIA Links

Campaign for the Freedom of Information

Office of the Information Commissioner,
who is meant to regulate the Freedom of Information Act 2000 in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Scottish Information Commissioner,
who similarly regulates the Freedom of Information Act (Scotland) 2002

Information Tribunal - deals with appeals against decisions by the Information Commissioners.

Freedom of Information pages - Department for Constitutional Affairs

Friends of the Earth FOIA Request Generator and links to contact details for Central Government Departments and their Publication Schemes

UK Government Information Asset Register - in theory, this should point you to the correct Government documents, but in practice...well see for yourself.

Access all Information is also logging some FOIA requests - prototype FOIA request submission, tracking and publication website

Blog Links

Spy Blog

UK Freedom of Information Act Blog - started by Steve Wood, now handed over to Katherine Gundersen

Your Right To Know - Heather Brooke

Informaticopia - Rod Ward

Open Secrets - a blog about freedom of information by BBC journalist Martin Rosenbaum

Panopticon blog - by Timothy Pitt-Payne and Anya Proops. Timothy Pitt-Payne is probably the leading legal expert on the UK's Freedom of Information Act law, often appearing on behlaf of the Information Commissioner's Office at the Information Tribunal.

Syndicate this site (XML):

Recent Entries

Recent Comments

  • Buy Backlinks: Love the blog here. Nice colors. I am definitely staying read more

November 2010

Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat
  1 2 3 4 5 6
7 8 9 10 11 12 13
14 15 16 17 18 19 20
21 22 23 24 25 26 27
28 29 30